Best Pizza in Sumter

Come Savor Sumter's Pizza Perfection – A Slice Above!

Order Online

Try our most popular items

Treat yourself to our must-try list that has everyone talking

View Full Menu

Cheesy Garlic Bread

Each

Add Item

Hand Cut French Fries

Add Item

All Meat Pizza (Medium)

Beef, sausage, Canadian bacon, pepperoni

Add Item

Billy Lane's Original Hand Tossed Crust!

Most folks like thin-crust pizza. We have had the same thin crust since 1979. Then some folks like a thick or hand-tossed type crust. We have developed a new crust that is thin in the middle and thicker on the edge. It's more like the original Neapolitan Old Country Crust. Double fermented, then hand formed. The center is thin and the edge is light, airy, poofy, and bubbly. This is also referred to as a cornicione edge. All that and Delicious! MEDIUM ONLY🍕

Italian Food with a Southern Accent

At Pizza Lane, come savor Italian food that speaks the language of the South, where every meal is served with a side of Southern hospitality. Each dish is prepared with a passion for tradition and a flair for local taste, ensuring that every bite delivers a unique experience.

Take it and Bake it!

We're excited to bring the warmth and flavor of our kitchen directly to your home with our Take n' Bake option. Imagine the aroma of freshly baked pizza aroma filling your space, anytime you desire. Our Take n' Bake service allows you to enjoy Pizza Lane at your convenience, preserving the taste and quality you've come to love. Whether you're planning a family gathering or simply craving a slice of comfort, just take it and bake it. It's our way of bringing the Pizza Lane experience to you

Dive into Pizza Lane's Buffet Bliss

Dive into variety at Pizza Lane's buffet—a flavorful feast with mouthwatering pizzas, fresh salads, and delicious sides. From classic Pepperoni to innovative slices, our all-you-can-eat experience is perfect for gatherings.

Order From Our Website

Order directly from our website to save money in fees, get faster service, earn free food via our rewards program, and support local business.

Order Online

What our customers are saying

Check out our most recent reviews!

This place was a referral from another restaurant we love and they were right it was awesome, glad we went and might be our new weekly place to eat.

Adam S.

We had an absolutely wonderful time at Pizza Lane today! We are so happy to see Ashley back! The restaurant was packed, the bar had FRESH food with more options than usual, it's the first time I've seen dessert and sides other than fries in the longest time. She checked on us so many times. The restaurant is undeniably better when she is there. She really knows what she is doing! We will be back soon! Kid-friendliness: It's definitely a fun place for children!

Kerin L.

My brother has Down syndrome and every time I come into Pizza Lane the waitress are super nice to him and treat him like a person not a disability! They will sir down with him and converse with him and that really makes his day! Plus the pizza is awesome too! My best friend had a gender reveal party here and it was amazing! I cannot day enough positive things about this place!!!